another birth reg query

[Guest]

am trying to find stuff I have left to one side for a while

This one probably is the hardest

Charles George Mack/Mack according to his Death and Will born 23 Jun 1907

http://person.ancestry.co.uk/tree/6737403/person/-403923207/facts

1911

http://interactive.ancestry.co.uk/2352/rg14_01627_0455_03/2839255?backurl=http://person.ancestry.co.uk/tree/6737403/person/-403923207/facts/citation/6165494938/edit/record

Mother Miriam Rebecca Gutantag/Rose born 1870 in Mile End . she calls herself Minnie Macks in 1911

I dont think she married the father of Charles although in 1911 she says she is a widow

Cannot find a birth for him anywhere

[vera2013]

The only thing I can find is

Rose no first names Registered

December quarter 1906
Vol 01C Page 274
Whitechapel

mmn Rose

However note that in the 1939 he gives dob as 23 June 1907

Vera

[Sylvia C]

Just throwing this out as "possibles" to be investigated ......

...... thinking in terms of my own grandfather who told everyone his birthday was not when I've found it to be :D

You mentioned surnames Gutantag, Rose, Mack, Macks


I found this on Freebmd .....

Births Mar 1906 (>99%)
Rose Charles George Richmond, S. 2a 530

but obviously wrong from GRO ....

ROSE, CHARLES GEORGE mmn MIDDLETON
GRO Reference: 1906 M Quarter in RICHMOND - SURREY Volume 02A Page 530

[vera2013]

Just ignore mine Val
Pretty sure that is the birth of a baby who died in the same quarter aged O Whitechapel.

Vera

[Guest]

thanks for looking people ,oh pooh Vera got excited then ,Sylvia that is interesting will look into him, as it was law to register a birth am surprised I cannot find him?

[margaretmarch]

thanks for looking people ,oh pooh Vera got excited then ,Sylvia that is interesting will look into him, as it was law to register a birth am surprised I cannot find him?

It could just be a mistake on the index.

You could try the local register office to see if they have it in their records.

Margaret

[Guest]

thats an idea Margaret thanks

[Olde Crone Holden]

Val
It was the law to register a birth but of course that doesn't mean that no one ever broke the law! Quite a few people even today don't appear to have ever been registered although I bet at least some of them WERE registered but not under the name you would expect!

OC

[Guest]

OC this is my Guttentags so nothing should surprise me about them really, I may be on to something as a tree on ancestry has him and whats more a photo of him and his wedding wow,have been in touch and between us we may solve it.