why does familysearch make you sign up with them (for free), only to tell you you must go to one of their centres or affiliated centres to view indexed records? only unindexed records can be viewed at home.....seems counter productive to me...unless they have a deal with FMP or ancestry in place? whereby these records will be uploaded to their site, so won't be freely publicly available for a certain amount of time? very frustrating.
Unconfigured Ad Widget
Collapse
Announcement
Collapse
No announcement yet.
familysearch images
Collapse
X
-
i)Some of the indexing is in a mess and ii)we don't all have access to a local LDS centre.
I would have been happier if they'd left them all unindexed and available for browsing through. Whilst browsing, I was able to ferret around and came across all sorts of treasures I wouldn't have discovered had I been using an index. I thought the relevant record offices had given permission for the IMAGES to be available online for ALL. At first, they were - now what we have available to us when working from home are transcriptions only, which are secondary sources and should always be checked against the originals wherever possible. It would have helped if they had at least made all the images available at county record offices. My "local" LDS centres are not very local and are not accessible by public transport. As they are run by volunteers, the hours are sometimes evenings only, and if volunteers are available. I am very disappointed with the current provision.
JayLast edited by Janet in Yorkshire; 25-02-19, 08:39.Janet in Yorkshire
Genealogists never die - they just swap places in the family tree
-
I am quite puzzled by all this.
The reason that the LDS church was allowed access to so many church records was their promise that these records would be available to EVERYONE, free of charge. I don't understand how they can now pick and choose which records are freely available and which are not.
I no longer have a local FHC because, as Janet says, it is run by volunteers, has very limited opening hours and often closes without warning. I am eternally grateful for the years when this centre ws available to me but I do feel sad that this wonderful resource is being quietly withdrawn.
OC
Comment
-
You can often get images by going direct to the catalogue instead of search.
I usually start with the county and work from there down to the parish. If there is a film for what I want then this is indicated by a small camera icon. It can take a while for all the images to download but often, eg for a marriage, there is an index within the first few images for the groom's name and giving the page number (not the image number so you need to scroll to find it). It is a struggle sometimes !
This blog demonstrates how it can be done if you get a transcription that has a film number on it. Note that it does not always work
Last edited by Katarzyna; 25-02-19, 10:27.Kat
My avatar is my mother 1921 - 2012
Comment
-
Yes that's true Jay.
What I don't understand is why we had been able to view these for many many years but their reason for not showing them now is "The microfilm may have been scanned, but have a contractual, data privacy, or other restriction preventing access". Surely that must have been in place from the time they filmed them???
I have Norfolk ancestors and they are still free to view BUT not Bacton where my 3X great grandfather was from. I had to go to the NRO but even they will not let you copy them as they don't have permission from the church.Kat
My avatar is my mother 1921 - 2012
Comment
-
Quite a few of the NE Norfolk parishes are no longer available, Kat. There are the ATs and BTs for some parishes, but they are not complete. My Kirks were in Bacton for about 6 years and I managed to find images of the bps I needed in the annual transcripts. But for a lot of my events, I can no longer view an image of the relevant PR entry. Moral of the story is, if you find an image you need, then download it pronto, before it gets whisked off into the ether.
A lot of people did a lot of transcribing for the LDS site, believing that they were helping to produce an index which would enable other to find, retrieve and access the images. Some of them are NOT happy about the development.
JayJanet in Yorkshire
Genealogists never die - they just swap places in the family tree
Comment
-
Originally posted by Janet in Yorkshire View PostQuite a few of the NE Norfolk parishes are no longer available, Kat. There are the ATs and BTs for some parishes, but they are not complete. My Kirks were in Bacton for about 6 years and I managed to find images of the bps I needed in the annual transcripts. But for a lot of my events, I can no longer view an image of the relevant PR entry. Moral of the story is, if you find an image you need, then download it pronto, before it gets whisked off into the ether.
JayKat
My avatar is my mother 1921 - 2012
Comment
-
Grrrr. In my notes I had a record of a 1776 marriage which took place at Hoveton St Peter, Norfolk. My source was recorded as an image from the parish records (so a primary source) which I'd viewed some years ago on family search. This image is no longer on family search, but turned up on Ancestry. Ancestry also had the Hoveton BTs/ATs - but 1776 is MISSING. Just the one BT (for 1776) is viewable on family search, but is just a note that a marriage took place in that village on that date and is a secondary source. (Seeing the original PR was important for me, because the groom was recorded as a widower, which tied in with my family an earlier marriage and subsequent burial of a young woman.) I also have in my notes a record that the groom was a mariner - again an important link in identifying the right groom out of several possibilities with the same fore and surname. I shall now have to go and "browse" for the marriage licence, these have not been indexed and are currently still on family search. I'm hoping 1) I can find it, and 2) it says mariner.
What a mess. Until the big change, familysearch was the most marvellous resource for Norfolk records.
And yes, I'm downloading and filing away any records I find.
JayLast edited by Janet in Yorkshire; 26-02-19, 16:06.Janet in Yorkshire
Genealogists never die - they just swap places in the family tree
Comment
-
Originally posted by Katarzyna View PostGood advice Jay. I think this applies particularly to anyone with a tree on ancestry or other online tree. Census, bmd, burials, wills passenger lists - everything you find - download to your computer and save on a usb memory stick or other storage device. I once spent 3 days downloading all the images I had saved to an Ancestry tree when I realised that once my world Subscription ceased I would not be able to view them again.Carolyn
Family Tree site
Researching: Luggs, Freeman - Cornwall; Dayman, Hobbs, Heard - Devon; Wilson, Miles - Northants; Brett, Everett, Clark, Allum - Herts/Essex
Also interested in Proctor, Woodruff
Comment
Comment